Child trust funds - are you getting the best return for your child?
Cash-based child trust funds (CTF) have delivered an average growth of just over 10% in the last two years. The average growth for equity based child trust funds however, is over three times as much over the same period.
Moneyfacts.co.uk has reviewed how much an initial investment of £250 would be worth today if it were invested at the start of the child trust fund scheme two years ago. The following chart reveals that cash based child trust funds have on average grown just over 10%, meaning your £250 investment would now be worth £276.
|
Provider |
£250 value as at 5.4.07 |
% Growth |
|
Abbey |
£271.40 |
8.56% |
|
Britannia BS |
£277.88 |
11.15% |
|
Furness BS |
£276.60 |
10.64% |
|
Hanley Economic BS |
£279.87 |
11.95% |
|
Nationwide BS |
£275.36 |
10.14% |
|
Skipton BS |
£276.82 |
10.73% |
|
Average |
£276.32 |
10.53% |
Compare this with the value of equity-based child trust funds. The table below reveals that the average growth of equity-based child trust funds is 34%, meaning that your £250 investment would now be worth £334 - which is nearly £60 more than a cash-based child trust fund.
|
Provider |
£250 value as at 5.4.07 |
% Growth |
|
Abbey National Multi-Manager Bal Intl Trkg B Acc |
£312.58 |
25.03% |
|
engage Investment Growth CTF Acc |
£329.48 |
31.79% |
|
F&C FTSE All-Share Tracker 1 Acc |
£353.65 |
41.46% |
|
Family Investments Child Trust |
£319.00 |
27.60% |
|
Halifax UK FTSE 100 Index Tracking D |
£335.59 |
34.24% |
|
HSBC UK Growth & Income Acc |
£338.69 |
35.48% |
|
Insight Investment Foundation Growth Retail Acc |
£345.26 |
38.11% |
|
Legal & General UK Index Trust R Acc |
£354.11 |
41.65% |
|
Liverpool Victoria Growth |
£358.37 |
43.35% |
|
Nationwide Tracker |
£350.17 |
40.07% |
|
Norwich UK Index Tracking SC 3 |
£373.01 |
49.20% |
|
Scottish Friendly Managed Growth |
£358.38 |
43.35% |
|
Scottish Widows Balanced Growth Portfolio A Acc |
£302.87 |
21.15% |
|
Total Average |
£334.30 |
33.72% |
Child trust funds are booming – with 49,000 child trust fund accounts opened in the first quarter of this year. However, nearly 75% of parents chose to invest their voucher in cash funds, meaning their children could be missing out in the long term.
It's great news that more and more parents are finally taking the time to invest their children's child trust fund vouchers. But, it certainly pays to take a little more time to consider whether investing in cash or equity based child trust fund will deliver a higher rate of return for your child.
But, a word of caution. Whilst the figures indicate that over the last two years equity based child trust funds far outperformed cash based child trust funds, past performance isn’t necessarily a guide to the future and equity based child trust funds can go up as well as down, so are a higher risk compared to cash child trust funds.
You can invest up to a maximum of £1,200 per year into a child trust fund, but stashing away all of your child’s savings into a child trust fund may not be a sensible move. All the money gets handed over to your child when they turn 18, and you can’t access it before then. Also, with the total value of child trust funds likely to be worth millions of pounds in 16 years time, who knows what the Government of the day will decide to do with the money?
So, our message is clear – make sure you invest your child trust fund voucher straight away, but consider the following strategy:
- Investing your £250 child trust fund voucher into an equity-based child trust fund involves a higher degree of risk, but could potentially deliver a higher longer term return for your child;
- You can offset the risk by saving money regularly into a tax-free mini-cash ISA, which then puts you in complete control over when your child can access the money.
What to do next:
- Read our guide to child trust funds
- Read our guide to mini cash ISAs
- Check out our Savings accounts best buys for cash child trust funds, equity child trust funds and mini cash ISAs
Other Articles:
- Charitable giving un-crunched
- Brits compare to marathon runners when it comes to money
- Saving Rate Guarantees
- Real effects of inflation and tax on Savings
- Proposed merger of Abbey and Alliance & Leicester
- Britons reduce savings as credit crunch starts to bite
- Moneyfacts.co.uk consistent savings survey (July 2008)
- Regular savers from reformed smokers
- Finance for Football Fanatics
- Young Adults 'Can Do' Money Website
- Egg's New Internet Savings Account
- NS&I Battles Brits' Money Muddles
- New 5-year Fixed Rate Escalator Bond
- Britain Reins in on Spending
- Children’s Savings Just Got Easier
- Saving For Deposits
- New Current Account Plus From The Co-operative
- Are Instant Access Savings Accounts Always What They Seem?
- 3G UK as Parents Move to Live With Children
- Market-Leading Premier Postal Savings Account
- Bank of England reduces bank rate by 0.25 percentage points to 5.0%
- Consistent savings survey (April 2008)
- Cash ISA survey
- Market Leading Fixed Rate ISAs Hit 6.25%
- Fixed Rate Cash ISA for Last Minute Investors
- Great Dating Expectations Take Toll on Men
- Savings - loyalty can pay if the account is right
- Market Leading 50 Plus Savings Account
- Don’t forget ISAs are changing…
- Budget 2008
- Plastic is fantastic for charitable giving – but only if you repay in full
- ISA war gathers pace
- Savings - What a difference a year makes!
- Regular Saving Parents Can Provide Nest Egg Worth £30K
- Savings Accounts and Car Insurance Strengthen Post Office
- Mini Cash ISA war kicks off early
- The biggest choice of savings best buys!
- Cash ISA Rates Reach New High (6.25%)
- Mini Cash ISA war kicks off early
- ISA Simplification Doesn’t Go Far Enough for Savers
- ISAs Could Generate More than £230 Million for Taxman
- Yet more bad news for savers
- At last, good news for savers
- Fixed rate savings best buys - blink and you'll miss them
- Family Savings Get a Helping Hand
- Savers still waiting to see if their rates will be cut
- Fixed rate savings take a tumble
- Icesave score a best buy hat-trick
- Consistent savings accounts (January 2008)
- Savers - fed up with big rate cuts and short term bonuses?
- Base Rate Ready Reckoner
- Christmas Savings for 2008
- Boost your savings in 2008
- Base rate update on Savings - two weeks on
- Credit crunch makes its mark on the base rate reaction
- It's not too early to be planning
- Savers benefit from the liquidity crisis as fixed rates rise again
- Northern Rock – encouraging new savers whilst discouraging new borrowers
- Savings - West Bromwich raises the bar, but with a catch
- It's not all good news for savers
- ASDA enters the savings market
- Savings accounts bonanza, but watch the small print
- Spend and save to support your charity
- Savings - Bonus bonanza
- The new over 50s current account from A&L pays 7%
- Barclays reduces its savings accounts rates
- Are your savings safe?
- The Moneyfacts.co.uk Manifesto
- Silver savings turn platinum
- Savings - fixed rate savings bonds - the best rates in 6 years!
- Most consistent savings accounts
- Code of practice for comparison websites is long overdue
- Moneyfacts.co.uk benefits from the Virgin effect
- Child Trust Funds – Take a Long Term View
- Child Trust Fund - What a Difference a Year Makes
- Hot Topic – Now your savings are even safer
- Savings Companies - Who Owns Whom? - The Listings
- Northern Rock Crisis - Don't panic, be savvy instead
- Travel money - don't Thomas cook it!
- Saga launches Internet savings account
- Lost savings - how to reclaim your share of £435m
- Spend, save and support your football team
- ICICI – Moneyfacts' stance
- How to earn an extra £1,000!
- Gordon Brown’s legacy
- The good, the bad, and the ugly (Jun 07)
- Online savings accounts the Sainsbury's way
- The good, the bad and the ugly (May 07)
- Being green doesn’t have to cost the earth
- Love and Money
- ISAs – Don’t Be Blinded by the Headline Rate
- Savers Beware - Rate Cuts Become More Widespread
- Child Trust Fund
- Savings Accounts Can Benefit You and Your Football Club
- A Gloomy Start for Savers
- Double-Digit Savings Rates – Too Good To Be True?
- Happy birthday Child Trust Funds!
- The Good, The Bad and The Ugly (Apr 07)
- ISA Survey 2007
- The Good, The Bad and the Ugly (Mar 07)
- 2007 Budget - Smoke & Mirrors?
- Barclays Tax-beater Cash Isa
- Save Hundreds of Pounds a Year!
- ING losing its shine
- Savers New Year Surprise
- Is Your Current Account Working For You?
- Valentines Day Financial Planning
- Top Tips For 2007
- Regular Savings Accounts
- Child Trust Funds
- Find a Better Home for Your Savings in 2007
- Is It Really The End Of Free Banking?
- Saving For Christmas 2007 Is Not As Mad As It Sounds
- Mini Cash ISAs - Don't Miss Out
- Giving Made Easy
- Instant Access Savings Accounts
- Children Trust Fund
- Savings Accounts for Over 50s
- Choosing Savings Accounts
- Cost of University
- Savings Interest Rate
- Savings Affinity
- Student Accounts
- High Interest Savings Accounts
- Banking and savings – customer service and reputation forefront in decision-making.
- Saving for your children
- Current accounts - wasted interest
- Identity Theft - Survey Statistics
- Four in five CTF vouchers invested in equities
- ISA Investment Growth
- Long Term Savings
- Mixed News on the Savings Front
- CTF first wave - 72% invested

