Is Yorkshire bank safe? -

Is Yorkshire bank safe?

Latest post Tue, Oct 14 2008 11:29 PM by northern scum. 7 replies.
  • Tue, Sep 23 2008 3:18 PM

    • Ian
    • Top 25 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Tue, May 27 2008
    • Wigan
    • Posts 15

    Is Yorkshire bank safe?

    I was thinking of opening a fixed rate term account with Yorkshire bank.They are owned by Australia,and seems Clysdale bank has registered with FSCS.Am i covered with Yorkshire.

     

    Filed under:
  • Tue, Sep 23 2008 3:21 PM In reply to

    • george
    • Top 10 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Tue, Jun 3 2008
    • sheffield
    • Posts 155

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

     clydesdale bank is shortly to become part of lloyds if govts agree

     

  • Tue, Sep 23 2008 3:21 PM In reply to

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

    Yorkshire Bank is owned by National Australia Bank Group but operates under Clydesdale Bank's banking licence.

    For more information please read our guide to who owns who and who has a banking licence.

     

    Filed under:
  • Tue, Sep 23 2008 3:23 PM In reply to

    • george
    • Top 10 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on Tue, Jun 3 2008
    • sheffield
    • Posts 155

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

     sounds like they may not be %100 safe then

     

  • Sun, Sep 28 2008 11:39 PM In reply to

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

    In terms of deposits, no bank is 100% safe.

    The Financial Services Compensation Scheme however guarantees 100% of deposits in a bank up to £35,000 provided that the deposit is lodged with an institution authorised by the FSA. You can see a list of authorised institutions on the FSA website http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/list_banks/2008/aug08.pdf

    Northern Rock is probably 99.99% safe as they have been nationalised and arrangements have been made by HM Treasury and The Bank of England to guarantee all deposits. I say 99.99% because, it is of course possible (but highly unlikely) that HM Treasury and The Bank of England would default on their guarantee. 

    That said, all of the other UK Banks registered by the FSA are effectively "only" 99.98% safe! If an authorised UK bank went into liquidation and depositors lost any money, the confidence in the UK as a global financial centre would be lost overnight and upwards of a million people would lose their jobs. Financial Services is such a crucial part of the UK's economy and is the single largest contributor to the UK balance of payments, that a failed authorised UK bank would be bailed out at all costs.

    Secondly, there seems to be some confusion on the thread - are you referring to Yorkshire Building Society or Yorkshire Bank? They are two separate institutions:-

    • "Yorkshire Bank" is a trading name of Clydesdale Bank. Clydesdale Bank is classed as an "authorised institution" by the FSA. Clydesdale Bank plc is in turn owned by National Australia Bank. The second largest bank in Australia. In terms of its size and as a comparison it is about the same as Lloyds TSB.
    • Yorkshire Building Society is the third biggest building society and is owned by its members (depositors). It is half the size of Clydesdale Bank and less than a tenth of the size of National Australia Bank.

    If you are referring to Yorkshire Bank, your passbook / statement will say Yorkshire Bank and carry their logo, but you are in fact banking with Clydesdale Bank and it will also say this in their passbooks, on their statements, on their leaflets / website / legal notices inside branches etc. This is in the same manner as:-

    • "Smile" which is a trading name of The Co-operative Bank plc
    • "NatWest" = National Westminster Bank plc, in turn owned by RBS Group
    • "First Direct" = HSBC Bank plc
    • "C&G" = Lloyds TSB
    • "Woolwich" =  Barclays Bank plc            etc etc etc .....

    Nonetheless, both Yorkshire Bank/Clydesdale Bank and Yorkshire Building Society are sound, well-run institutions which is evident from their external credit rating (Moodys, Fitch S&P etc). Neither institution has any significant issues as a result of the "credit crunch" as they fund the the majority of the loans they provide from their own depositors funds (unlike Northern Rock who used less than 30% of their own depositors funds and 70% of other banks depositors funds which suddenly were not available when the inter-bank market effectively closed last year - imagine being able to rely on a £20 billion overdraft for years and then having withdrawn overnight).

    That is not to say the two Yorkshire's will not be affected by the "credit crunch" as they will have to pay a higher rate to borrow on the money market and they will inevitably incur more bad debts as their borrowers feel the pinch and go into arrears - these will of course be over publicised because its grabs headlines, but these are issues for the shareholders to worry about, not depositors. Bad debts are part of banking, they are expected by banks and they make a provision for them each year.

    In terms of investing - you have no need to worry about depositing funds in an account with authorised UK bank. However, investing in the shares of a bank is a totally different matter as you could lose the everything as did the shareholders of Northern Rock (and probably Bradford & Bingley tomorrow).

    Hope this reassures you and puts into perspective the alarm that the media thrive on. If not you could of course stuff your money under the mattress. There are a number points to consider:-

    • it also has a fixed rate of return ( 0%)
    • you don't have to queue up to withdraw it
    • there is no deposit protection scheme. Should your house get broken into, you would lose the lot (actually - your house insurance may cover the first £100) !

    Best wishes

    PM

     

  • Mon, Oct 13 2008 10:26 PM In reply to

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

     

    and where did u get this info from lol

     

    i work for the clydesdale bank and we have been gettin daily updates and there has been to talk of lloyds taking over, we are owned by national australia bank .

     

  • Mon, Oct 13 2008 10:32 PM In reply to

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

    oops i mean no talk of it lol

     

  • Tue, Oct 14 2008 11:29 PM In reply to

    Re: Is Yorkshire building society safe?

     

    In summary all bar my 4th paragraph is complete fact – from the detail I went into you will appreciate I have numerous sources. I will not breach confidences, but you can check out the facts yourself on a variety of websites and you will see that they do not contradict anything I say or each other.

     

    As you would expect I have obtained information directly from both Yorkshire Bank and Yorkshire Building Society – much is freely available on their websites which are:-

    • Clydesdale Bank plc trading as Yorkshire Bank       www.YBonline.co.uk
    • Yorkshire Building Society                                       www.ybs.co.uk

     

    Of course the cynic in you will say that irrespective of what “re-assurance” messages a bank/building society puts on its website most people look for  independent impartial opinion based on fact. This can be obtained from a number of sources, but try the following for starters:-

     

    The following are Government / regulated body websites:-

    • Companies House                                   www.companieshouse.gov.uk
    • The Office For National Statistics              www.statistics.gov.uk
    • The Financial Services Authority             www.fsa.gov.uk
    • The Australian Stock Exchange               www.asx.com.au
    • British Bankers Association                      www.bba.org.uk
    • Building Societies Association                  www.bsa.org.uk

    The following are individual global credit rating agencies, you may have to subscribe to get detailed reports:-

    • Moodys                                                    www.moodys.com
    • Standard & Poors                                    www.standardandpoors.com
    • Fitch                                                        www.fitchratings.com

    My 4th paragraph is of course opinion, but the Government has little option but to support the UK's banks to protect depositors and to maintain the confidence in the UK Banking system (this is to ultimately retain the UK's position as one of the leading global financial centres and all the spin offs that go with it). They have already proved this to be the case with the following actions:-

    ·         Northern Rock - nationalised

    ·         Bradford & Bingley - nationalised

    ·         HBOS (nationalisation initially avoided by turning a blind eye to competition rulings)

    ·         RBS & Lloyds TSB effectively nationalised via the bank rescue fund.

    ·         They have even agreed (in principle) a rescue plan for the UK depositors in the Icelandic Bank “Icesave”. Do I need to go on???

     

     

    Finally, Lloyds are not going to take over Clydesdale Bank (or NAB).  Think about it – how on earth could they fund the purchase?

    Lloyds TSB/ HBOS are already relying on massive amounts of charity by going cap in hand to the tune of £17bn from the Government’s bank rescue fund. This is last resort distressed funding provided to support their core business - not for unnecessary expense / speculative investments / take over bids etc...      

Page 1 of 1 (8 items) | RSS
© 2008 Moneyfacts.co.uk Limited. All Rights Reserved. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the Company's General Terms of Use & Privacy Policy. Moneyfacts.co.uk Limited is registered in England and Wales, company no. 6615303. Registered office: Moneyfacts House, 66-70 Thorpe Road, Norwich NR1 1BJ. Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Services Authority. Shown on the FSA Register (www.fsa.gov.uk/register) register number 486048.The Moneyfacts.co.uk logo, Moneyfacts and Money£acts are Registered Trade Marks.
None of the information contained in this website constitutes, nor should be construed as Financial Advice.